NFLIllegal Motion Original

The Colts Blow It Up: Quenton Nelson Heads to Seattle and DeForest Buckner Goes Back to the 49ers in a Tuesday Sell-Off

Two weeks before the deadline, a 2-5 Indianapolis team moved its best offensive lineman and its best defensive lineman in the same afternoon. Seattle and San Francisco, NFC West rivals, each got one. Here's what every side gets out of it.

San Francisco 49ers defensive lineman DeForest Buckner, No. 99, in the 49ers' white jersey and gold helmet on the field before a 2016 preseason game
Photo: Jeffrey Beall / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 (edited: resized, cropped, black and white)
Advertisement

The Indianapolis Colts didn't wait for the deadline. They started the sale on Tuesday.

In one afternoon, the 2-5 Colts traded eight-time Pro Bowl guard Quenton Nelson to the Seattle Seahawks and defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to the San Francisco 49ers, sending two of the faces of the franchise to the same division for draft picks (Colts.com, AP, NFL.com). It comes days after the team fired general manager Chris Ballard last week (AP, ESPN, NFL.com).

The trade deadline is Nov. 10, two weeks away (NFL.com, ESPN). Indianapolis might not be finished.

Advertisement

Deal terms per the official Colts, Seahawks and 49ers announcements as reported by Colts.com, Seahawks.com, AP, ESPN and NFL.com. Records through Week 7. Times are PT. Clocks fall back Sunday morning, Nov. 1, so Sunday and Monday kickoffs below are PST.

The two trades

Player Going to Colts get
G Quenton Nelson Seattle Seahawks 2027 third-round pick, 2028 fifth-round pick
DT DeForest Buckner San Francisco 49ers 2027 fourth-round pick

Seattle announced the Nelson deal as pending a physical and waived guard Christian Haynes to clear a roster spot (Seahawks.com, NFL.com).

Seattle gets a Hall of Fame résumé for a third-round pick

The numbers on Nelson are ridiculous. The No. 6 overall pick in 2018 has made the Pro Bowl in each of his first eight seasons (Colts.com, Seahawks.com, NFL.com, ESPN) and was a first-team All-Pro in each of his first three (Colts.com, Seahawks.com). The only other offensive lineman to open a career with eight straight Pro Bowls was Joe Thomas (Seahawks.com, ESPN).

He's 30 and in the final year of a four-year, $80 million contract (NFL.com), so this is a rental unless Seattle extends him.

For the 4-3 Seahawks, it's about the line. Rookie Grey Zabel is expected to slide over to right guard, which would send Anthony Bradford to the bench (ESPN, NFL.com).

It's also very on brand for general manager John Schneider. He traded for Leonard Williams in 2023, Ernest Jones in 2024 and Rashid Shaheed in 2025, all during the season (NFL.com, ESPN).

Advertisement

Nelson can debut quickly. Seattle hosts the Bears on Monday Night Football, Nov. 2, at 5:15 p.m. PST (ESPN).

Buckner goes home

San Francisco took Buckner No. 7 overall in 2016, then traded him to Indianapolis in 2020 for a first-round pick (Colts.com, NFL.com). Six years later, he's back.

He's 32, a three-time Pro Bowler (AP, NFL.com), and he's still producing: 4 sacks and 31 tackles in seven games this season (Colts.com, NFL.com). He's also on an expiring contract, and he'd made his frustration with the losing clear (AP, NFL.com).

The 6-1 49ers are on bye this week (ESPN), which gives Buckner a few extra days to settle back in before San Francisco's Week 9 game.

What it means for Indianapolis

Two veterans, three picks, and a very clear message. Here's where the Colts' extra picks now stand from Tuesday's deals (Colts.com, AP):

  • 2027: third-round pick (from Seattle), fourth-round pick (from San Francisco)
  • 2028: fifth-round pick (from Seattle)

The bigger question is who's next. Jonathan Taylor and other veterans have already been named as trade candidates (NFL.com). The Colts play at Jacksonville on Sunday at 10 a.m. PST (ESPN).

Our take (opinion)

This is opinion, not reporting.

Seattle wins this trade. A third and a fifth for an eight-time Pro Bowler is a steal, even for half a season. If Nelson and Zabel turn the interior into a strength, Seattle's offense gets a lot harder to stop.

San Francisco wins it too. A fourth-round pick for a familiar, productive pass rusher on a team sitting at 6-1 is exactly the kind of move a contender should make.

The Colts did the right thing, two years late. Getting value for players on expiring deals beats watching them walk. But a third and a fourth for the two best players on the roster tells you how little leverage Indianapolis had left.

And now the NFC West has both of them. The Seahawks and 49ers will see each other again this season, and that game just got a lot more interesting.

Fantasy angle: what Nelson means for Seattle's backfield is in our Week 8 fantasy rankings.

Reported as of ~9:35 a.m. PT, Wednesday, Oct. 28, 2026.

Advertisement